Skip to main content

BriCargo Group

FOB vs CIF: Costs and Risks for Canadian Importers

FOB vs CIF changes who arranges and pays for ocean freight and cargo insurance. It does not normally change when risk transfers: under Incoterms® 2020, both transfer the risk of loss of or damage to the goods to the buyer when the goods are on board the vessel at the port of shipment.

For Canadian commercial imports, FOB (Free On Board) leaves the main freight arrangements to the buyer. CIF (Cost, Insurance and Freight) requires the seller to arrange and pay for freight and specified insurance to the named destination port. CIF does not automatically include delivery to your warehouse or every Canadian arrival charge.

Compare both offers through to the same final address. For containerized cargo handed to a carrier before vessel loading, also check whether FCA or CIP better matches the shipment.

Need help arranging the transport? Explore BriCargo’s import freight forwarding to Canada.

FOB vs CIF at a glance

FOB and CIF are rules for sea and inland-waterway transport. The comparison below describes normal performance under the agreed Incoterms® 2020 rule.

FOB and CIF responsibilities under Incoterms® 2020
Responsibility or check FOB CIF
Named port in the contract Port of shipment. Port of destination for the seller-paid freight.
Origin delivery and export clearance Seller delivers the goods on board and handles export clearance. Seller delivers the goods on board and handles export clearance.
Main ocean freight Buyer arranges and pays. Seller arranges and pays to the named destination port.
Cargo insurance The rule does not require either party to obtain insurance. The buyer can arrange cover. Seller must obtain the insurance required by CIF for the buyer’s risk.
Normal risk-transfer point On board the vessel at the port of shipment. On board the vessel at the port of shipment.
Destination unloading and handling Check the buyer’s freight contract and its inclusions. Seller pays unloading where its carriage contract puts that cost on the seller. Check other arrival charges and avoid counting included charges again.
Canadian import clearance, duties and taxes Normally the buyer’s responsibility. Normally the buyer’s responsibility.
Onward delivery in Canada Normally arranged and paid for by the buyer. Not automatically included beyond the named port; confirm any separately agreed delivery.

Scroll sideways to view the full table.

The distinction is payment versus risk: the seller can pay the ocean freight under CIF while the buyer carries the transit risk. The ICC FOB and CIF rules set out these responsibilities.

How to compare FOB and CIF quotes

When comparing CIF vs FOB, hold the goods, quantity, currency, cargo-ready date, origin and final Canadian delivery address constant. A supplier’s CIF port price and a forwarder’s warehouse-delivery price cover different endpoints until you reconcile their inclusions.

Start with each supplier price. Then add only the buyer-paid costs that are not already included. Under CIF, do not add the same seller-paid ocean freight or insurance again. If one supplier offer begins with collection at the factory, use EXW vs FOB to check the different origin responsibilities.

If an offer excludes a cost normally assigned to the seller by its stated term, resolve the difference in writing before using the totals.

FOB gives you control over selecting the main freight arrangement. CIF lets the supplier arrange that part of the shipment. Neither is automatically cheaper or better: compare the full cost, routing, insurance and clarity of the offer.

Subtracting a guessed freight percentage from a CIF price does not produce a reliable FOB quote. Ask for the actual breakdown or a separate FOB offer.

Supplier quote comparison worksheet

Shared shipment details: goods and quantity ___ · currency ___ · cargo-ready date ___ · origin ___ · final Canadian address ___

For each entry, record inclusion status, amount and currency, payer, and quote validity or reference. Use “included,” “additional,” “not applicable” or “unconfirmed.” The blanks below are not zero amounts.

Blank quote-comparison worksheet: use identical shipment details
Cost or check FOB offer + separately arranged freight Supplier CIF offer
Supplier quoted price — starting amount ___ ___
Origin costs outside the supplier’s scope ___ ___
Main ocean freight ___ ___
Cargo insurance or additional cover ___ ___
Destination terminal, unloading and deconsolidation ___ ___
Release and documentation charges ___ ___
Customs brokerage ___ ___
Inland delivery to the final address ___ ___
Duty and applicable additional trade measures ___ ___
Import GST/HST and other applicable taxes ___ ___
Known variable or conditional charges ___ ___
Excluded or unconfirmed items requiring follow-up ___ ___
Estimated total cash outlay, counting each amount once ___ ___
Eligible recoverable import tax already included above ___ ___

Scroll sideways to view the full table.

The cash budget starts with the supplier price plus additional buyer-paid amounts. Do not subtract recoverable tax from the cash needed to pay the shipment’s bills. If recovery is available, show the eligible amount separately when comparing the economic cost after recovery; subtract it only once and only if it was included in the total.

Keep the total provisional while charges remain unconfirmed. This worksheet is a shipment budget, not a customs valuation calculation.

What charges may still be due in Canada?

“Freight paid to the port” does not mean every arrival cost is paid. Ask which charges are seller-prepaid, buyer-payable or still unconfirmed. Not every item below applies to every shipment, and some may already be included.

Potential Canadian arrival charges and checks
Potential charge What to confirm
Terminal handling, unloading and LCL deconsolidation Which services the freight price includes and who invoices any remainder.
Cargo release and documentation Which carrier, agent or terminal charges remain payable.
Customs brokerage The broker’s service scope and fee, separately from government duties and taxes.
Duties, taxes and additional trade measures The cargo-specific assessment and who will arrange payment.
Examination-related logistics Potential movement, handling or storage if cargo is selected for examination.
Storage, demurrage or detention Applicable free time, charge triggers and responsibility for returning equipment.
Inland delivery The final address, delivery appointment and any special unloading requirements.

Scroll sideways to view the full table.

If the supplier instead offers delivery to a Canadian destination under DAP or DDP, compare DDP vs DAP. Those terms allocate destination and import responsibilities differently from FOB and CIF.

Customs value and import tax are separate checks

Your landed-cost budget is not automatically the value used to calculate customs duty. Under Canada’s transaction-value method, transportation adjustments depend on the place of direct shipment and what is included in the price. Applicable adjustments require actual, supported costs; do not assume the overseas port is always that place or use a standard freight deduction. Ask your broker to apply the CBSA transportation costs and customs value guidance to the shipment.

Duty depends on tariff classification, customs value, origin and tariff treatment. Additional measures, including anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties or surtaxes, may also apply. Use the CBSA guidance on Canadian import duties and taxes to verify the relevant treatment.

Imported goods are generally subject to GST or the federal portion of HST, except for qualifying non-taxable importations. The import-tax base can include duty and excise tax. Eligible GST/HST registrants may recover qualifying import tax through an input tax credit, subject to the applicable conditions. See the CRA’s GST/HST on imported goods guidance before treating any tax as recoverable.

When FCA or CIP fits containerized cargo

A container is often handed to a carrier or terminal before it is loaded onto the vessel. That physical handover and the FOB/CIF on-board risk point can be different. The ICC container-shipping guidance helps match the rule to the actual delivery process.

FCA when you arrange the main freight

Under FCA (Free Carrier), you arrange the main carriage and the seller delivers at the agreed place. At the seller’s premises, delivery occurs when the goods are loaded onto the buyer-arranged transport. At another named place, delivery occurs when the goods arrive on the seller’s transport, ready for unloading and at the disposal of the nominated carrier or person. Identify the precise handover point because it determines delivery and risk transfer.

CIP when the seller arranges carriage and insurance

Under CIP (Carriage and Insurance Paid To), the seller pays carriage and insurance to the named destination. Risk normally transfers on delivery to the carrier at the agreed delivery point—typically the first carrier when several are used—not on arrival at the paid-to destination.

Under Incoterms® 2020, CIF normally requires Institute Cargo Clauses C or similar cover, while CIP normally requires the broader Clauses A or similar cover, subject to agreement. Broader cover does not cover every loss. Check the certificate, insured journey, limits, deductibles, exclusions and claims procedure against the CIF and CIP insurance requirements.

FCA and CIP work across transport modes and may better fit container or multimodal movements. Whether you use a shared or full container is a separate decision; LCL vs FCL explains that choice.

What to confirm before accepting the quote

Ask the supplier and freight provider to confirm:

  • The exact term: rule, named port or place and Incoterms® 2020 edition. Keep ownership and payment terms explicit in the sales contract; Incoterms do not determine them.
  • The cargo: supplier details, goods description, quantity, packed piece count, dimensions and weight, plus any special handling requirements.
  • The movement: cargo-ready date, origin address, final Canadian address and pickup or delivery requirements.
  • The price scope: included and excluded services, currency, validity, conditional charges and who pays each item.
  • The insurance: who arranges it, required cover, insurer, certificate, limits, deductibles, exclusions and claims contact. Confirm where cover starts and ends, including whether any onward Canadian leg is covered.
  • The arrival arrangements: importer and broker responsibilities, release process, free-time terms, delivery planning and equipment return where relevant.
  • The documents: commercial invoice, packing list, transport documents and any cargo-specific origin or regulatory documents identified for the shipment.

Resolve exclusions before comparing totals. A lower headline price is useful only when you understand what remains to be arranged and paid.

Request an import freight quote

Have a supplier’s FOB or CIF offer? Send the quoted term and named port or place, goods description, packed dimensions and weight, cargo-ready date, origin and final Canadian address. Include the supplier’s freight inclusions and exclusions so the remaining transport scope can be assessed.

BriCargo coordinates commercial imports to Canada, including LCL and FCL ocean freight. Supplier pickup and inland delivery can be arranged as appropriate, with coordination through a licensed customs broker or your existing broker. The required services depend on the cargo, route and supplier’s agreed scope.

Request an import freight quote